The New Analog Productions Atlantic 75 Series Release
LINK TO VIDEO
If you're a vinyl enthusiast, chances are you've found yourself asking whether you really need another copy of Yes: Fragile. I know I’ve wondered the same. But then again, when it's an Analog Productions release we're talking about, the curiosity naturally piques. This time, it's the new Atlantic 75 Series release, and after living with it for a few weeks and comparing it to several other versions of this classic, I’ve got some thoughts that might just convince you it's worth adding to your collection.
A Recap of the Past Evaluations
Before diving into the specifics of this new release, it’s worth mentioning that I did a thorough shootout a few months ago, comparing eight different versions of Fragile. In that evaluation, I included UK Plums, Mobile Fidelity editions, the Steve Hoffman-cut Analog Productions release, Kevin Gray’s 2016 edition, and pressings from places like Canada, Australia, and more. If you're into audiophile records, it’s a video worth checking out (I'll link it below).
The Yes: Fragile Versions I’ve Listened To
Let me quickly recap some of the standouts from that shootout before I get into this new release.
UK Plums: While collectible, these versions didn’t quite cut it for me. They have a slightly bright tone that’s not very forgiving and lack a deep bass response. The clarity is there, but vocals and busy parts can get grainy. If you have a good system, you’ll probably want something a little better.
Steve Hoffman Cut (Analog Productions): This was a step up. The clarity was superb, and the bass was much improved. Vocals and separation were on another level, making it a very listenable version. The only downside, however, was that the excitement of the top-end energy was slightly tamed. It's a great option, but it lacked some of the energy that makes the best pressings so engaging.
Mobile Fidelity One-Step: A lot of people love the Mobile Fidelity Fragile, especially because it’s a 45 RPM pressing. The top end is absolutely gorgeous—never harsh, with wonderful clarity and separation. The issue I found, however, was the bass. It's deep and sometimes too boomy. While it’s fun, the extra bass can muddy the overall balance and even slightly cloud some of the delicate high-end detail. Still, tracks like "Heart of the Sunrise" really shine on this version.
Kevin Gray's 2016 Cut: This was the surprise winner of the shootout. For a more affordable pressing, the 2016 edition blew me away. It offered the best balance of excitement and detail. The mid-range was clear, the vocals were fantastic, and the bass was perfectly balanced with the rest of the spectrum. It’s a great $25 option that really competes with the high-end releases.
The New Analog Productions Atlantic 75 Series Release
Now, onto the main event—the new Atlantic 75 Series pressing from Analog Productions. Is it worth it? Let’s break it down:
Sound Quality: Right off the bat, I could tell that this new release builds on everything that Kevin Gray's 2016 cut got right, but with even more refinement. The high-end is smooth, yet the excitement is still there. The clarity and separation are absolutely top-notch, but without any harshness. The bass is powerful but not overdone, anchoring the music without overwhelming the rest of the spectrum. If you're familiar with the 45 RPM version, this new one manages to capture many of its strengths while addressing some of its pitfalls.
Dynamic Range & Power: This new release really stands out when it comes to dynamics. The extra power and clarity make the sound more open and detailed, much like the 45 RPM Mobile Fidelity version, but without the excess bass. It’s a balanced, coherent experience, and the soundstage feels expansive and rich. The ability to capture both delicate details and massive, soaring moments is impressive.
Packaging and Presentation: As always, Analog Productions does not disappoint with the physical presentation. The jacket is a gorgeous gatefold, and the overall quality of the pressing and packaging is excellent. The deep saturation of the blue on the cover is a treat, and it's evident that a lot of care went into making sure this is a visually stunning release.
Should You Add This to Your Collection?
For those of us who love the 45 RPM experience, this release offers a nice compromise—gaining much of the sonic benefits without the sometimes overpowering bass. The new Analog Productions Atlantic 75 Series Fragile is a refined and enhanced version of Kevin Gray’s 2016 cut. The dynamic range, improved clarity, and overall balance make it a worthy addition, especially if you’re not a fan of 45 RPM pressings but still want to experience the sonic excellence that Fragile has to offer.
If you’re a die-hard audiophile, you’ll definitely appreciate what this new release brings to the table. Whether you’re just diving into the world of Yes or you’re a longtime fan, this edition should not be overlooked.
In conclusion, yes, you probably do need another copy of Yes: Fragile—if you’re a collector and audiophile looking for the most definitive pressing. The 75 Series release is certainly a winner, and it beautifully improves upon the strengths of previous cuts. If you're already into the 45 RPM versions and love the Analog Productions label, you’ll find this a highly recommended addition. If you’re not a fan of 45s but want something that enhances the 33 RPM experience, this one’s for you.
Enjoy the music, and happy listening!
